Introduction
It’s a bold proclamation that challenges the status quo in musculoskeletal care. This statement, originating from Scott Herbowy, a world-renowned physical therapist, emphasizes the need for a paradigm shift in how we diagnose and treat pain and dysfunction. It's not an indictment of medical professionals but a critique of a system that frequently misguides patients towards unnecessary procedures with often unsuccessful outcomes.
The Gap in Medical Education
While the narrative is shifting, still to this day the majority of people believe that if you or I have a pain or injury we go to our primary medical doctor first. This isn’t necessarily wrong, BUT is it the best decision to get the best guidance for the best outcome you want? In most cases, it isn’t. Now if you have a traumatic injury like breaking a bone then yes for sure the Emergency Room is the best place to go, but outside of trauma like a hard hit or fall, going through a highly qualified chiropractor or physical therapist is going to be the best bet to get the best guidance on what to do.
Here's why: The inadequacy of musculoskeletal education in medical training is startling. According to research published in the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, less than 5% of a medical doctor’s education is dedicated to musculoskeletal health, despite it being one of the most common areas of patient concern. This gap is evident as 82% of medical school graduates fail basic exams in this field. The Clinical Orthopedics and Related Research Journal highlights that this lack of training leads to doctors who are unprepared to tackle musculoskeletal issues effectively, which can result in misdiagnosis or suboptimal treatments and interventions. Within the 5% of training, it is often a broad overview rather than hands-on training or in-depth anatomy, leaving significant gaps in this critical area, particularly in primary care settings.
Furthermore, a 2015 study published in the Journal of Physical Activity and Health revealed that only 13% of U.S. medical schools offer any dedicated course on physical activity, with many programs reporting fewer than five hours of focused training over their entire curriculum. While I'm not suggesting that medical doctors need to match the musculoskeletal and exercise expertise of physical therapists and chiropractors, this stark statistic brings us to a critical realization: we often entrust the direction and management of our injuries and pain to medical professionals who may have limited training in exercise science and musculoskeletal health. Ironically, this expertise is crucial not only for recovering from pain and injuries but also for achieving long-term health and wellness.
So, what kind of training do chiropractors and physical therapists receive? According to a study in the journal Physical Therapy; Doctor of Physical Therapy (DPT) programs in the U.S. include 500-600 hours of specialized coursework in musculoskeletal health, encompassing hands-on training in evaluation, treatment techniques, and therapeutic exercise. Chiropractic education mirrors this with a strong emphasis on spinal health and alignment. Additionally, professionals like Dr. Justus and I enhance our expertise with over 500 hours of advanced education in diagnosis, biomechanics, injury rehabilitation, manual therapy, strength training, and comprehensive recovery strategies to effectively manage and alleviate some of the most challenging pain conditions.
This level of detailed and specialized training equips us to act as 'traffic controllers' for individuals suffering in pain, directing them to the appropriate care. If they are candidates we can help, we offer not just temporary relief but lasting solutions, empowering our patients to achieve optimal health and reclaim their lives from pain.
The Implications of Misdiagnosis
Misdiagnosis is not just a medical error; it's a significant contributor to patient suffering and increased healthcare costs. The Spine Journal notes that misdiagnosis rates for lower back pain—one of the most common complaints in primary care—reach up to 40%. Similar misdiagnosis rates apply to conditions like plantar fasciitis and carpal tunnel syndrome, often leading to unnecessary interventions. These statistics reflect the broader issue of a healthcare system that too often relies on a superficial understanding of symptoms without probing deeper into their root causes.
The Misleading Nature of Imaging
Imaging techniques, though advanced, can mislead treatment directions. The New England Journal of Medicine discusses how imaging, such as MRIs and X-rays, often detects anomalies like disc degeneration or rotator cuff tears in a significant portion of asymptomatic individuals. These findings complicate the diagnostic process, as the presence of these conditions in images does not necessarily correlate with the patient's pain or functional impairment. This disconnect can lead to over-treatment, including unnecessary surgical interventions.
Understanding Patient Experience
The personal experience of pain is highly subjective and can vary widely among individuals, as detailed in the Pain Research and Management Journal. This subjectivity means that two patients with the same injury may report different levels of pain based on individual thresholds and contexts. Understanding this variability is crucial, as it requires a tailored approach to treatment that considers the psychological and social factors influencing each patient's pain perception.
The Power of Mechanical Exams
Mechanical exams are dynamic and provide a real-time insight into how a patient's body functions and responds to movement. According to the Journal of Orthopedic & Sports Physical Therapy, mechanical diagnosis and therapy (MDT) offer a robust framework for understanding the mechanical causes of pain. By observing and manipulating how a patient moves, clinicians can identify dysfunctional patterns and devise interventions that are much more targeted and effective than those based on static images alone.
Moving Forward
The pathway to effective treatment involves a comprehensive approach that integrates a detailed history, symptom review, and a mechanical examination. This strategy ensures that treatments are not just palliative but curative, addressing the root causes of pain and dysfunction to facilitate long-lasting recovery.
Conclusion
Next time you face a musculoskeletal issue, remember that while doctors, patients, and MRIs might not always tell the full story, a thorough mechanical exam rarely lies. It’s about getting to the heart of the issue through dynamic assessment, not just static imaging.
Call to Action
Don’t settle for temporary fixes or accept pain as an inevitable part of life. Book a discovery visit today to uncover the true origins of your symptoms and start on a path towards genuine, sustainable health and well-being.
PS: Stay connected and informed by following us on Instagram for the latest updates and insights into effective musculoskeletal care: Auxoma Instagram.
Dr. Tyler Panko
Contact Me